Question 1

Why are SEO checklists a waste of time for Shopify brands?

Accepted Answer

Four reasons: (1) Not all checklist items are equal — optimizing a meta title has a vastly different impact than adding image alt text, but a checklist treats both as equivalent checkboxes. (2) Most checklist items won't noticeably improve rankings or revenue — out of 100 items, approximately 10–20 are actually high-impact. (3) Checklists create a false sense of completion — finishing all 100 items does not mean ranking at position one. (4) Generic checklists can't account for where the brand is in its market, what kind of site it is, or what specific gaps need to be closed to rank for specific keywords.

Question 2

What is the most common mistake in the order SEO checklists present their items?

Accepted Answer

Technical SEO is almost always listed first on SEO checklists. But content and links — not technical SEO — are what actually move rankings most significantly. Following a checklist in order means spending hours or days on technical SEO before getting to the activities that produce rankings. This wastes time, creates frustration, and delays doing the things that actually make money.

Question 3

What does an actual Shopify SEO strategy look like vs. a checklist?

Accepted Answer

A real strategy consists of: keyword research for collection pages, product pages, and any blog content; identification of the backlink gap on core keywords (e.g., position one has 20 backlinks, the brand has 1 — a 19-link gap); a content creation and link building cadence based on budget and timeline (e.g., building 5 links per month closes a 19-link gap in approximately 4 months); and ongoing iteration based on what Search Console and ranking data shows is working. It is specific to the brand's current position in its market, its competitors, and its revenue goals.

Question 4

Is image alt text important for SEO?

Accepted Answer

It is a low-leverage SEO task. Adding image alt text to a page that currently ranks at position two will not automatically move it to position one. Adding image alt text to a page on page ten will not automatically move it to page one. In contrast, optimizing a meta title — which takes approximately 30 seconds — will often have a more significant ranking impact than days or weeks of technical work. Both tasks appear on most SEO checklists as equivalent line items. They are not equivalent.

Question 5

What is a backlink gap and how is it used in an SEO strategy?

Accepted Answer

The backlink gap is the difference between the number of backlinks pointing to the current page being ranked and the number pointing to the top-ranking pages for the same keyword. If position one has 20 backlinks and position two has 15 backlinks, and the brand's page has 1, the gap is roughly 14 links to reach position two and 19 links to reach position one. Knowing this gap and knowing the monthly link building budget (e.g., 5 links per month) produces a realistic timeline: approximately 3–4 months to close the gap at that rate. This is what a strategy looks like — specific targets, specific timelines, specific resource allocation.

Question 6

Does the agency use SEO checklists?

Accepted Answer

No. None of the agency's SOPs include checklists. Everything in SEO is too nuanced between brands to be captured by a generic checklist. A checklist can't account for the brand's current market position, its competitors' link profiles, what content already exists on the site, or the specific keywords that will drive revenue. A strategy built around specific keywords, specific link targets, and specific cadences will always outperform a generic checklist approach.

SEO Checklists Are a Waste of Time — Here's What an Actual Strategy Looks Like

Why Checklist Items Are Not Equal

The Order Problem

What an Actual Strategy Looks Like

Frequently Asked Questions

Work With Us

Why SEO Best Practices Won't Work for Your eCommerce Brand